ۼ : 13-06-11 17:32
( 2012. 2. 29. )
 ۾ :
ȸ : 5,940  
    .hwp (32.0K) [18] DATE : 2013-06-11 17:34:16
ƯħؼҼ۰ ɰҼҼ

ȯ *


I. 
II. ƯҼ Ϲ
III. 2004 10 28 20006914 ǰ
IV. ƯħؼҼ۰
V. սɸ
VI.

I.  


뷮δ ߱ c ѱ ,
뵿뿡 ɸ° İ ü ϴ ̴.
̸ ѱ â ȣ ȭϷ ϰ ,
Ư Ư ϰ Ư
ذ پ õ ǰ ǰ ִ.

Ư ϰ Ưû ֵ Ʒ żϰ ̷ ִ ݸ,
Ư , ȣü پ ô ذ ̴.
̷ Ư õ ɰҼҼ۰, Ư õ ħؼҼ ̿ Ǿ
Ⱓ ̾ ƯҼ ū ǰ Ѵ. 

ƯҼ ƯҼ۰ ƯҼ зȴ.
ƯҼ 284 Ư ҷ Ǿ ִ Ҽ̶,
ƯҼ ƯҼۿ Ư ûҼ(Ư 126),
عûҼ(ι 750), ſȸġûҼ(Ư 131)
ħؼҼ۰ Ư ͼ ѷ Ҽ, ׸ Ưû óп Ҽ Ѵ.

̱, Ϻ, ,  Ư
 Ư ȿ Ǵܰ ħؼҼ ϵ ϴµ ,
ѱ Ϲݹ ħؼҼ۰ ðó ϰ ִ.
, ɸ ޾ ϰ ִ Ư ,
ٴ ɸ Ͽ, ȿ ϴ.
ħؼҼ κ Ư㹫ȿҼ̳ ǸȮμҼ ߺǾ ǰ,
Ҽ ־ ʿϴٰ Ư㿡 ɰ Ȯ
Ҽ Ƿ(Ư 164 2),
ħؼҼ ϴ Ϲݹ Ǻδ Ư Ư㹫ȿҼ
Ǵ ǸȮμҼ Ȯ ħ Ǵ ٸǷ,
Ư ȭ ⵵ ӵǰ ִ.

̿ ذϱ , ̱ ȸ׼ҹ(Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, CAFC) ̳
Ϻ Ǽ ʸ ߿ ǰ ǰ
ȣ簣 Ǿ Ȳ̴.

, 200069614ǰῡ ħؼҼۿ
Ư㹫ȿ Ǵ ϴ ð ,
ϱ޹ ǰῡ ̸ ϴ 찡 ߰ߵǰ ־
ǿʹ ݴ Ҽ۽ǹ ǰ ִ ̴.

ҼҼ۰ ħؼҼ սɸ ʿ伺 θ Һ 忡 ľϰ Ѵ.
̸ ܱ 캸, ѱ Ǹ ذ 캻.


II. ƯҼ Ϲ

1 ܱ ƯҼ

  ̱ 1982 Ư μ ȸ׼ҹ ġϿ.
Ư Ҽ ϿȭϿ Ҽ ȿȭ Ƿ ϼ Ȯ ޼ϱ ̴.

̱ Ư ȣϸ鼭 밡ɼ ö ؿٰ,
1980 Ư ȭϰ
ϰ ϴ Ư㺸ȣ ߽÷ å ȯϿ.
ȸ׼ҹ ġ Ư㺸ȣ ȭ ޹ħϱ ¡ ̴.
ƯҼۿ ̱ ȸ׼ҹ Ư ȣ ū ⿩ ߴٰ 򰡵ǰ ִ.

Ϻ 1990 Ȳ غϱ Ͽ,
Ư, ǿžȱ, ݵü ȸ, α׷ ۹ з
λҼ ׼ҽɰ Ưû ɰῡ ҺҼ ϴ ǼҸ 2005⿡ Ͽ.

, Ư õ Ҽ
1ǵ Ǽҿ īǼҷ ߽
ǰ żӰ Ƿ ϰ ִ.
߰ Ҿ ħؼҼۿ Ư ȿθ Ǵ ְ Ͽ,
ȣ簡 Ҽ۴븮 ֵ Ͽ.

ѱ Ư, Ư㹫ȿ ǻǿ ǽɿ Ǹ ϴ ,
Ưû Ưǿ Ǵܿ ؼ ο ո̰ ȿ ϱ
1998 Ư ġǾ.



2 ƯҼ

 1. ƯҼ

ƯҼ 28 4 1ȣ Ư ҷ Ǿ ִ Ҽ ɰҼҼ̴.
ɰҼҼ ɰҼҼ۰ ڰ ɰҼҼ зǸ, ̴ ڸ з̴.

Ǹ̸ ǰ Ưû Ǵ ɰҼҼۿ
ɻ Ư ɰҼҼ, ƯҰ ɰҼҼ,
׸, ɰҼҼ ִ.

Ưû ڷ , Ǹڿ Ҽ
ڰ ɰҼҼۿ Ư㹫ȿ ɰҼҼ, ǥҽ ɰҼҼ,
Ư ӱⰣϹȿ ɰҼҼ, ǸȮν ɰҼҼ,
ȿ ɰҼҼ, ׸ ǽñ㿩 ɰҼҼ ִ.

ǹ ƯҼۿ Ҽ۴븮 糪 ȣ Ǵ Ư̳ ִ.
׷, ȣ糪 쿡 븮 ϰ 溯ȣȸ ݵ ÷εǾ ,
쿡 ȸ ̷ Ȳ̴.

 2 ƯҼ

  ƯҼۿ ƯҼ۰ Բ ħؼҼ, Ư ͼ ѷ Ҽ,
׸ Ưû óп Ҽ ִ.
Ưû óп Ҽ Ư
Ư (Ư 2242, 2)Ǿ ,
߸ Ư, ° õ û,
׸ Ư Ǹ Ȯ Ҽ ̷ Ư ͼ ѷ Ҽ۵
ü װ ϹǷ Ϲ λҼۻ .

ħؼҼۿ Ư 126 ƯûҼ,
Ư 131 ſȸġûҼ,
Ư 128 ι 750 عûҼ
üδ Ϲ λ ̶ .

׷, ħؼҼ κ Ư㹫ȿ Ǵ ǸȮν
(̷ ɰῡ Ҹ ϴ Ҽ ƯҼ Ư ̴) ߺǾ ǰ,
ħؼҼ ϴ Ϲݹ Ǻδ ɸ 
ħؿθ Ǵϱ ƴ.
ħؼҼ ϴ ħ Ǵ Ưǿ ɰö
Ǵ Ư ɰҼҼ Ȯ
Ҽ Ƿ ٸ Ǿ Ǵ ɰϴ.
 

III. 2004 10 28 200069194 ǰ


1

Ư 133 Ư㿡 ȿ ϴ 쿡
Ưǿ Ư㹫ȿ ؼ Ư㸦 ȿ ֵ ϰ ִ.
ħؼҼ ϴ Ư ȿθ Ǵ .
׷ ռ 캻 ħؼҼ ذϱ ,
ƯħؼҼۿ ڰ μ ħؿΰ ִ Ư ȿ Ѵٸ,
ȿ ɸ Ǵ ִ ΰ Ǵ ̴.

, Ư ħؼҼ ɸϴ Ư ȿɰ ȮDZ ̶
Ư ȿ ο Ǵ ִ ȿ Ưǿ
ع û Ǹ뿡 شϴ ΰ
Ҽ ذå ִ Ǵ ̴.

2 Ƿ µ

1992 6 2 91540 (Ưħرóл)
Ư ϴ ̻ ̿ ǿ Ͽ Ư㸦 ȿ Ѵٴ ɰ Ȯ ʴ ȿ ̸,
Ư㸦 ȿ ִ ִ
ٸ Ҽ μ Ư㰡 翬ȿ Ǵ ̶ ǽϿ
ȿ ̿ Ư 翬ȿ ,
Ư߸ Ϻ Ǵ ΰ 쿡 Ư㹫ȿ ɰ
Ǹ ̶ ϸ鼭 Ģ ܷμ
űԼ 쿡 ȿ ̿ Ư Ǹ ִٰ ǽϿ,
ƯħؼҼۿ Ư㹫ȿ ׺ ٴ и 򰡵ǰ ,
ǰ ټ ǰ( 1998 10 27 972095 ǰ,
1998 12 22 971016 ǰ ) Ǿ.

Ư߸ Ǵ Ϻΰ ̾ Ǹ ʴ
, űԼ ʾ Ǹ Ǵ 츦 л ̶ܼ ϸ
ü ǰ(1983.7.27. 8156) 961750 ǰ(1997.11.11.) ޹ħȴ.

3 200069194 ǰ

  1.

Ư ħؼҼ ߿ Ư߸ ɰ ȮǾ
ǰῡ λҼ۹ 451 1 8ȣ ɻ Ƿ,
ǰ ǰῡ ģ ıǾ Ѵٶ ϸ鼭
Ư ȿɰ ȮDZ ̶ ϴ
ƯħؼҼ ɸϴ Ư㿡 ȿ ִ ο Ͽ Ǵ ְ,
ɸ Ư㿡 ȿ ִ и
Ưǿ ع û Ư
Ǹ뿡 شϿ ƴѴٰ ̴ٶ ̰ ־
Ϲ Ư ȿθ Ǵ ִٰ ִ .

  2. ǰ

Ҽ۴븮 Ưǿ 20022405ȣ ɰ Ͽ ϸ,
ɺ 2004. 6. 29. û Ͽ
Ư߸ Ưû 1 ' ⸲
巳 ׽(2) 󿡼 ϴ ȸ Ī (23)' κ,
' ⸲ 巳 ׽(2) 󿡼 ϸ,
(16) ǥ鿡 ع ƴϴ ִ ȸ Ī (23)',
' ǥ(16)', ' ǥ(24)' ϰ, 'ϰ ǰ,
(16) 巳(4)' κ '(16)' ϴ οϴ ɰ ,
ɰ û ۴޵Ǿ¹,
ɰ  ûο ۴޵ν Ȯǰ,
Ư߸ Ͽ Ѵٴ ɰ ȮǸ ɰ ȿ ñ ұϿ
Ͽ Ư, , Ư Ǵ ɰ Ư ƾ ϹǷ
Ưû ߸ ȮϿ ϸ,
Ư ȿɰ ȮDZ ̶ ϴ
ƯħؼҼ ɸϴ Ư㿡 ȿ ִ ο Ͽ Ǵ ְ,
ɸ Ư㿡 ȿ ִ и
Ưǿ ع û Ư
Ǹ뿡 شϿ ƴѴٰ ̴ٶ Ͽ.

3. ǰ

Ϲ Ư ȿθ Ǵ ִ ؼ ִ µ ϰ ,
Ǹ뿡 ǽó ǰ ı ΰ κ̰
ֱٱ Ȯ 忡 ־ ߾
Ϲ ħع Ǹ ׺ ִٴ α Ȯ ؼϴ Ϳ ؼ
ǹ̶ ü ̴.



IV. ƯħؼҼ۰


1 ƯħؼҼۿ Ǵ

1. ȿ

̶ ڰ ϴ
ڰ 翬ȿ ƴ ִ ҵDZ ȿ Ǵ ȿ Ѵ.
һ Ǵ
û Ͽ ҵǰų Ͽ ҵDZ ȿ ǰ,
ұ λ̳ ȿ ȴ.

Ư û Ưû ֱ
ȴٰ Ϲ̴.

2. Ư㹫ȿ

翬ȿ Ư㹫ȿǿ ȿʹ ٸ ̹Ƿ,
ϴ ϰ ϵ Ư Ͽ ִ Ư㹫ȿǿ ؼ ȿ ִ ̴.
Ư㹫ȿ ҿ ҿ ſ Ÿϴ.

3. 翬ȿ

Ư߸ Ǵ Ϻΰ ̾
Ǹ ʴ űԼ Ǵ 캻.
̷ ٰŷ 翬ȿ õDZ⵵ Ѵ.
شϴ ߸ Ư㸦 ο ߴϰ ڰ ִٴ ̴.

׷ شϴ ߸ Ư㸦 ο ߴϰ ڶ ִ ǹ̴.
Ǹ ϴ Ư㸦 ȿ ȮϿ ִ ƴϱ ̴.
翬ȿ ̷ ٰŰ ٰ ,
̷ ٰŴ Ǹп ϴ Ÿ ̴.

4. ƯħؼҼۿ Ǵܽ

űԼ Ǵ 쿡 شϴ п ã´ٰ Ͽ,
Ǵܿ ̸ Ȯϴ DZ ƴ.
Ǵ ϴ Ưǿ, Ư ɿ ϴ ̱ ̴.
׷Ƿ, ƯħؼҼۿ Ϲ λ Ǵϰ Ǹ Ưǿ Ư Ѽϰ ȴ.

ʴ´ٰ ϴ, űԼ Ư ʰ ʾҴٸ
з ȣ ִ ̾ ̶ ⵵ ƴ.

Ư Ǹ縦 Ǹ
Ư Ǹ縦 ι ų ־ Ǹ ͵ ִ.

쿡 ʹ ޸,
̳ Ǹ ٰŷ Ͽ ƯħؼҼۿ Ǹ ϴ ٰ Ÿϴ.

2.

ƯħؼҼۿ Ǹ ϴ ̷ ٰŰ ѵ,
Ϲ λ Ư ޸ ɸ ־ .
, ȿǿ ȿ ȮDZ Ǹ Ͽ ̴.

, ƯħؼҼ Ǵ 쿡 ħ ȿ ϴ 찡 κ̱ ,
ƯħؼҼ ٷ ȿ Ȯ ɸ Ͽ Ҽ Ǵ ̴.
ħؼҼ Ǵ ڱݷ Ưڴ , , ǿǿ ϰ Ǵ ߻Ѵ.


V. սɸ


1

2002 λҼ۹ 24  Ư żϿ,
ŷ Ҹ ϴ 쿡
Ǵ Ư ִ ⸦ ,
ִ ⸦ ֵ ƯĢ Ͽ.

̴ ε, ִ , , , 뱸, λ
Ըμ о Ǻΰ ġǾ ̴.

ǰ̰ ҿ Ͽ ΰ, ø ǹ̸ Ƿ,
õ ϴ ˣ ûֿ ϴ ϴ
ǿ Ҹ ϴ ǰ û
ǹ õ ҹ , ûָ ϴ
õ ϴ ߾
ø ұ , ˣ Ҹ ϸ ȴ.

̴ Ϻ , Ư õ
λҼ Ǽҿ īǼҿ 1 ߽Ų δ.
, Ϻ ߽Ų ̶ ѱ ߰ Ϳ Ұϴ.

2 ̼

λҼ۹ 36  Ҽ ̼ żϿ.
ǿ Ҹ ִ ֵ Ư Ͽµ,
⿡ ƴϰ ϹݿĢ ƴ 쿡
ִ ̼ ֵ ̴.

ϴ ͸δ, Ǻο ǻ ȿ ó Թ ޼ϱ Ƿ,
̶ ü ̼ۻ
ִ Ǵ û ̼ ϵ Ͽ.
쿡, س ϱ ʿ並 䱸 ,
̼ۿ Ҽ ϰ ǰų Ӱ ̼ .

, λҼ 1ɿ Ǻ ֵ ϰ,
1 Ҽۿ Ͽ ұ ִ ̼ ϵ ϰ ִ ̴.

, Ǻΰ ġǾ ִ Ư ޸,
ɸ ħؿ ü ȴ.
2008 Ե ɸ ɸ Ѿ
÷ ɸ ̹Ƿ ɸ ¿ ǵ ȴ.

Ұ Ҽ̼ Ȱϰ ̷, Ǻο ̷ٰ ϴ
ħؼҼ ׼ҽ Ϲ ̷Ƿ,
Ưǿ ɰ Ư ϴ ɰҼҼ ȮǾ߸ ϴٴ ̴.
ħ ׼ҽ Ư ߵ ʴ Ȳ
1ɿ Ǻ Ǵ ޴´ٰ Ͽ Ҽ .

3 Ҽ۰

ܱ ޸ ѱ Ư 225 Ư ħ˸ ϰ ִ.
Ҽ ο Ȯ ϴ ,
Ǹ Ȯ ϴ λҼ۰ ٸ.
Ư ɸ ̴ λҼ Ǹ ɸĢ Կ Ͽ,
Ҽ Ϳ ̹Ƿ ǿ ϰ ִٴ ̴.

λҼ۰ Ҽ ޸ϴ ־
ǰ ٸ ʰ ϳ ڷᰡ ̴.
׷ ó λҼ۰ Ҽ Ͽ
θ ſ Ͽ 򰡰 Ͽ Ҽ۰ ϰ ִ.
׸Ͽ Ҽ  Ưʹ Ҽۿ δϿ λå ִ ϰ ֱ⵵ ϴ.

ó ɸ ̰ ִ Ҽ۰ λҼ۵ δϿ óϴ ϵ
ǰ , ϰ ż ϱ ̴.
׷Ƿ, ħؼҼ۰ ɰҼҼ ó ̴.
ٸ, ħؼҼ۰ ޸ Ҽ ɰҼҼ۰ ɸϴ ǰ ʿϴٰ .

4 Ư ħؼҼ ʿ伺

캻 ٿ , λҼ۹ 1 ʿ伺 ϸ鼭
ϴ ƴϰ ұ ״ Ͽ.
̴ Ǻΰ ġǾ ִٰ ϴ Ǻ£ Ưȭ 1 ġǾ ִ ƴϱ ̴.
ǰ 鵵 ִٰ .

׷ ׼ҽ 쿡 ޶. μ Ư ü پ,
ִ Ư ħ θ ľ ִ
ɸ ִ ȮǾ ֱ ̴.
ħؼҼ ȿ ϸ鼭 ̸ ׺ϴ Ϲȭ Ȳ,
ɸ ȣ ִ ǰ żӰ Ư 쿡 شȭ ̴.

ٵ ħؼҼҼ۰ ɰҼҼ ִ ,
¼ ڽž Ҽå ̿ ִٴ ū .
ħؼҼ , Ư ǰ Ǹ ħϿ ұϰ, ħؼҼ
Ҽå Ưû Ư ûϰ,
ٽ Ư ɰҼҼ ϴ Ҽ Ͽ Ǹ Ǹ ϰ ִ ̴.

Ư Ǹڰ ߼ұ̰ ڰ ,
Ư ذ ٸٰ ־,
δϰ ݾ ȭظ ϴ ʰ ־ ߼ұ ǿ Ѵ.
̿ ̱, Ϻ Ư ִ κ 󿡼 Ư äϴ ̴. 

VI.


2002 λҼ۹ ǿ ϰ,
̿ ؼ ̼۱ ϵ Ư ɸ Ǻο óǾ ν߱ ̶ .

׷, Ǻδ ƴϹǷ ɸ ġ ޹ħ ʴ´.
, Ұ ̼ Ǻο Ǵ ޴´ٰ ϴ,
ȿ ɰҼҼۿ ȮǴ ο ū ҽ ȴ.

Ư ɸ° ħؼҼ ׼ҽɿ Ӱҹ Ǵ 䱸Ǵ ̴.
Ǹȣ Ǹȣ ̰, Ҽŭ ֻ ŷڸ ġ ,
Ҽ Ȱ Ǵ ̱ ̴.

2011 5 19 ⺻ ó лǾ ִ å
â, ȣ, Ȱϵ ϰ ִ.
21 ú żϰ ϰ ذϱ
Ҽ ȭϰ ذ Ȯϱ Ҽü踦 ϵ Ͽ.
̷ Ҽü ù Ư ħؼҼ ׼ҽ ϴ Ϳ ؾ ̴.

<Abstract>
Discussions on jurisdiction centralization of patent infringement and cancellation proceedings lawsuits


The revised Code of Civil Procedure allows for broad jurisdiction over matters
relating to Intellectual Property rights as well as for transfer of trial.
Behind this is the thought that the patent cases should be handled by a professional judging panel.
However, even the specialized court is not supported by technical specialists.
The broad jurisdiction and transfer system can not still resolve the problem of delayed cases
because invalidation trials and appeals to the decisions are proceeded in a separate court.
Thus the one solution to avoid delays in enforcing the Intellectual Property rights is to centralize
the patent-related cases such as infringement lawsuit and appeal proceedings to Patent Court.


: ħؼҼ, ҼҼ,
Key words: infringement lawsuit, cancellation lawsuit, jurisdiction centr
alization